Hasan Minaj called me an a**hole on “Patriot Act” last night. Here’s the video. Start around 4:00 to see ME. But the entire show is worth watching. I’m a big fan of the show and I like the simple format.
This episode was about whether college is worth it. I think by the end of the show, he agrees with me.
College is, of course, not worth it. It wasn’t worth it when I first wrote about this in 2005 in my column in The Financial Times. And every year since, but particularly now, it’s become even more worthless.
A) Tuition has gone up higher than inflation EVERY YEAR since 1977.
B) In 2000, graduates had $100 billion in student loan debt. Now: $1.6 TRILLION in student loan debt.
It used to be kids would graduate college and then have opportunities to become innovators, inventors, etc. The U.S. always gets its innovations from the young and hungry. Now, this generation is doomed to working shit jobs and making TikTok videos.
C) Georgetown University once called me out in a study about salaries for grads vs. non-grads. They quoted my articles on this and said I was wrong.
First, Georgetown “University” is a bit biased on this issue.
Secondly, their data was based on people who went to college 30–40 years ago. It was a different world then.
Third, companies ranging from Google to Ernst & Young no longer look at degrees in the hiring process.
Lastly, their study was scientifically flawed. No control group. The only real way to do this study is to take people who were accepted to all the same colleges as the group that was analyzed… BUT decided not to go to college. Otherwise, there’s no control for demographics.
Lesson: if you are biased when doing a scientific study, make sure you follow the rules of the Statistics 101 textbook that you teach at your school.
D) Why are colleges raising tuition? To pay for the increased costs of administration.
For instance, the president of Quinnipiac College (where?) makes $3 million. That’s a pretty hefty salary.
When Harvard took $9 million in CARES stimulus money a few months ago to keep paying salaries, who were they paying? Harvard’s endowment has $41 BILLION. Why did they need to take $9 million? Well, the head of Harvard’s endowment makes… $9 million. So I guess they were keeping employees paid after all.
E) Student loan debt is the one debt (including credit card debt, mortgage debt, IRS debt, etc.) that doesn’t go away in a bankruptcy.
So, in other words: Let’s loan to the youngest, riskiest group we possibly can… up to a quarter of a $1 million — even though they have zero collateral… and THEN let’s seize all their wages if they can’t pay it back.
F) Quick quiz (don’t Google) for college majors:
- When was Charlemagne born (the man who first united Europe)?
- Who was the president before Lincoln?
- If the vice president dies, followed by the next person in line for the presidency, and then the next person… who becomes president?
- What’s the symbol for copper on the Periodic Table?
I ask these not to show that people are stupid. I couldn’t answer two of them AS I WAS WRITING THEM.
The point is: We learn these throughout high school and college. And in 100% of the talks I give, when I ask the first question, nobody ever gets within 200 years of the right answer.
People only learn when they love a subject. I didn’t start learning any of the skills for the careers I succeeded in (or failed in) until AFTER college.
Even lawyers learn on the job. They are taught for the bar exam, but they learn the skills needed while on the job. I know this because I occasionally give talks at law firms about the latest nuances in law (I’m not a lawyer).
G) Kids say, “In college you learn to socialize.”
Harvey Mudd College (where?) is $75,000 a year. It doesn’t take $75,000 a year to teach an 18-year-old how to make friends or (realistically) have a ton of sex.
Also, college was the last time in my life I was friends with people my own age. Now, maybe 5% of people I know are the same age as me.
H) If you want to succeed at acting, act. If you want to be a computer programmer, program. Etc.
Do not spend four years wasting time learning theory when you can be doing. They are not the same.
I) College is one of the biggest causes of income inequality.
Only the top 1% can afford college. But even if you borrow the whole thing, there are enough extra costs, plus the debt burden, so that only the top 1/3 of society can go to college.
Andrew Yang addressed this on the Joe Rogan podcast.
Plus, college kids tend to marry college kids… non-college kids marry non-college kids… and the income inequality gets wider across generations.
Income inequality is not about how one person gets paid more than another. It’s about how entire generations create richer/poorer versions of the haves/have-nots
Colleges sent everyone home last March and did not refund money or even dorm rent money (except in one or two cases where they were sued and decided not to fight it).
The problem is: People go to colleges that are “accredited” under the assumption this will help them get a job good enough to pay down their debt.
Solution: Accredit the good online schools like (not a full list): Coursera, Masterclass, LinkedIn Learning, LessonFace, Udemy, Teachable, Udacity, Khan Academy, Code Academy, etc.
“Nano-degrees” can be earned in a fraction of the time and at a fraction of the cost and actually give you MORE real-world skills.
As a side note, Scott Young, author of “Ultralearning” and a guest on my podcast, once completed MIT’s four-year computer science degree in less than a year using their online courses.
He completed every assignment, took the tests, etc.
Someone on Reddit said, “But he didn’t get the degree.” And an employer, correctly, responded, “I’d hire him over someone who took the degree because of his initiative.”
The pandemic has even further underlined the reasons not to go to college. If your choice is to learn online for $75,000 a year or online for $2,000 a year from better teachers, then the choice is now obvious.
Take online courses and learn skills. And if you have skills, CREATE an online course. It’s a very lucrative business to be in.
Finally, there are many important real-world skills that are simply not taught in college. Most investing courses are too theoretical and are useless in real life.
Many computer science courses are not useful. I majored in computer science. It was the only subject I got good grades in, but once I was working in the “real world,” I was so ill-prepared I had to take two months of remedial classes in order to be the worst person at my job.
PEOPLE SAY, “THIS IS EASY FOR YOU TO SAY — YOU WENT TO COLLEGE.”
- See above. It’s unclear what I learned. And then I had to pay down my debt plus interest.
- I skipped a year and graduated in three years to lessen my debt load. I paid for every dollar of tuition.
- If I’d had a three-year head start, it’s hard to predict, but at least I would’ve been debt-free and probably learned the skills I needed more quickly.
- Tuitions are 3x higher now, or more.
- Nothing I do now has anything to do with what I learned in college. There was no “world wide web” then, for instance.
I have five kids. One is about to graduate but he went to school in another country where it was much cheaper and it took three years.
One is not going. One dropped out (better to actually ACT than study acting. She takes classes on the side that are better and 1/50 the price). One is taking a gap year and one MIGHT start next year but we’ll see with these lockdowns (I am against her going).
Final story: I got an email in 2011 from a student at [prestigious Ivy League school] saying he would put me in a wheat thresher and saying some other things.
I reported him to campus police since colleges are CHAZ-style autonomous regions and have their own police force.
The head of security at the school said, “Oh yeah, we know about this guy. He threatened a librarian. But listen, he’s about to graduate. Do you really want to report him?”
I never heard from them again.
I looked the student up recently and I think he works now at PBS.
Good luck everyone!
James Altucher is the author of the bestselling book Choose Yourself, editor at The Altucher Report and host of the popular podcast, The James Altucher Show, which takes you beyond business and entrepreneurship by exploring what it means to be human and achieve well-being in a world that is increasingly complicated. Follow him on Facebook and Twitter.
Image courtesy of Vasily Koloda.